Mystic Rock Golf Course

Golf Course Review by: Billy Satterfield

The Takeaway:  A centerpiece to the extravagant Nemacolin Resort in SW Pennsylvania, Mystic Rock makes no apologies for the over-the-top experience showcased by a grand waterfall on the 5th hole, a towering leaderboard on the closing hole, as well as statues, and of course rocks, throughout. While plenty challenging, the course is more fun and forgiving than other Dye layouts and worthy of its distinction as one of the finest casino resort destinations in the country.   Grade B+

Quick Facts

Designer:  Pete Dye in 1995

Cost:  $95.00 - $225.00 (includes GPS cart, driving range, forecaddie during daylight hours but not gratuity) Click for current rates

Course Website:  Mystic Rock's official website    Phone Number:  (724) 329-6111 or (844) 366-0789

Directions:  Get here! - 1001 Lafayette Dr., Farmington, PA 15437

Signature Hole:  5th - 598 Yard Par 5 - Mystic Rock's over-the-top nature is on full display for the 5th hole where this downhiller plays to a green framed on the left side by a waterfall, pond, and John Daly statue sitting under the 84 Lumber logo. From one tee box up, this hole is significantly shortened and becomes much easier to reach in two. On the approach shot for this hole players must decide between which angle of attack they want to come in from as the fairway splits to a high side and a low side. The high side keeps you away from the water that frames the left side but it also leaves you a shallow angle of attack when going after the green. It is an attractive and memorable hole with a fitting tribute to Mr. Hardy's 84 Lumber company that made building the course possible.

Waterfall and 84 Lumber logo at the 5th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Club (598 Yard Par 5)
Waterfall and 84 Lumber logo at the 5th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Club (598 Yard Par 5)

5th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (598 Yard Par 5)
5th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (598 Yard Par 5)

Photos:  See additional photos of Mystic Rock - - Please note, some of the photos in this review and link are property of Nemacolin Resort.

Accolades:  Ranked 8th in Pennsylvania on Golf Course Gurus' Best in State rankings.

What to Expect:  Mystic Rock was built in 1995 on the 2,000 acre Nemacolin Woodlands Resort that Joseph Hardy III purchased in 1987 and turned into a AAA Five Diamond resort hotel. Located 70 miles south of Pittsburgh, the resort is an impressive spread with five lodging options totaling 322 rooms, a luxurious spa with 40 treatment rooms, five swimming pools, 15 dining options, a casino, a multimillion dollar art collection, a plethora of outdoor activities ranging from tennis, to shuffleboard, to mountain biking, to rock climbing, to paintball, to shooting and archery - let alone 36 holes of great golf. The former home of the 84 Lumber Classic PGA Tour event, Mystic Rock can stretch out over 7500 yards and stand as one of the most challenging courses in the country with a 77.0 rating. The course is partially a golf experience and partially a visual and art experience as Mystic Rock has a large waterfall next to the 5th green, rocks creating retaining walls for fairways and water features, and multiple statues on display including Vijay Singh, Gene Sarazen, and John Daly among others. While the course is challenging, selecting the appropriate tees for your skill level makes all the difference in the world since the fairways and greens are relatively generous and certainly easier to handle than many diabolical Pete Dye designs. The result is a great blend that makes a course tough enough to host the best players in the world while still catering to the traditional resort player. In the end, the more traditional layout and extra bling of Mystic Rock makes it the preference of the two courses at Nemacolin for many visitors.

By the Numbers:

Tees Par Yardage Rating Slope
Championship 72 7526 77.0 149
Blue 72 6831 73.5 139
White 72 6300 71.2 136
Gold 72 5668 68.0 127
Red (Women) 72 4848 68.8 125


Individual Hole Analysis

Best Par 3:  12th - 185 Yards - Options make great golf holes Dye uses an unique option here by building two greens. Just one green is in play each day, but the option creates multiple angles of attack to enjoy during different rounds which can often be difficult to create on one-shotters. Both greens are built at the back of a pond and a forced carry must to executed to reach either one. A small inlet separates the two putting surfaces and I'm sure it is relatively often the case where the wrong green is hit and a precarious par save scenario is presented. Devoid of any bunkering, it is a fun hole that you'll look forward to playing each time around.

12th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (185 Yard Par 3)
12th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (185 Yard Par 3)

Side view of the 12th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (185 Yard Par 3)
Side view of the 12th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (185 Yard Par 3)

Best Par 4:  2nd - 473 Yards - Not only is the 2nd hole a great design, it is one of the toughest challenges of the day. A Gene Sarazen statue is your lone onlooker as he waits to see if you can navigate away from the two fairway bunkers that pinch the landing zone. The more bold you are off the tee by challenging the larger of the two bunkers, the more the reward on the angle attacking the green. The putting surface is protected by a large bunker on the left which can distract you from the real peril on this hole which is the small pot bunker hidden between the green and large bunker. Ending up in this bunker might as well be a one stroke penalty because getting up and down from there will take Phil Mickelson sauce.

2nd Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (473 Yard Par 4)
2nd Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (473 Yard Par 4)

Best Par 5:  11th - 634 Yards - The most dramatic hole at Mystic Rock is this three-shot par five that will tease and impress you from start to finish. The tips are tucked way back and below the fairway and appear to rarely be used as the path to them if not very beaten. The uphill tee shot leaves some mystery as much of the landing area remains out of view for players which can cause uncertainty with your driver, but be assured there is more room available than meets the eye. Upon cresting the fairway, players are afforded a stunning view of a downhill fairway ahead of them and a lake claiming the right side of the hole. With the green bending right in a peninsula fashion towards the water, a risk/reward element comes into play on the approach shot where only the most confident, and long, players will challenge the putting surface in two. Players laying up will allow themselves to go pinseeking on their third shot in an effort to attack any hole location with hopes of walking away with a birdie. The views from the hole are the best on the course.

11th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (634 Yard Par 5)
11th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (634 Yard Par 5)

Birdie Time:  13th - 394 Yard Par 4 - I enjoy an unsuspecting hole. Off the tee it looks ordinary and then when your reach your ball for the approach shot the hole unveils an impressive display. The dogleg right 13th falls into that category as the main view off the tee is a bunker 250 yards in the distance on the right side along with a group of trees blocking the view of the green. Upon reach the corner of the dogleg, the hole unveils an attractive scene of bunkers, trees, and a raised green wrapped on the side and back with water. A lone tree on the edge of the pond stands as an iconic figure leading up to the putting surface on the right side. Not very lengthy overall, leaving the driver in the back is a good decision here where accuracy is favored over length so that you set yourself up in good shape for going after the wide but shallow green.

Tee shot at the 13th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (394 Yard Par 4)
Tee shot at the 13th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (394 Yard Par 4)

Side view of the 13th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (394 Yard Par 4)
Side view of the 13th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (394 Yard Par 4)

Bogey Beware:  9th - 476 Yard Par 4 - The closing hole on the front nine is a worthy test by anyone's standard. The late left dogleg brings a pond into play on the left side starting 220 yards from the tee. The landing area is just 24 yards wide so length and accuracy will be required on the tee ball before eyeing the approach shot. The green is long and narrow with a skinny bunker breaching the left side and a small, deepish bunker at the front right corner of the putting surface so you'll need to display some finesse around the green as well. This is a stout test that will requires your 'A' game from start to finish to avoid a bogey.

9th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (476 Yard Par 4)
9th Hole at Mystic Rock Golf Course (476 Yard Par 4)